Political

Molokai and Hawaii – Island Politics

Molokai Enterprise Community Plans to Cancel Public Elections

Friday, May 9th, 2008

(UPDATED 5/10/2008) KAUNAKAKAI, HAWAI'I:  On the eve of its tenth and final year of federal funding, the Moloka'i Enterprise Community (EC), Ke Aupuni Lōkahi, Inc., is taking final steps to exclude the community from its board by planning to cancel regularly held elections.

On April 17, in a meeting that was closed to the public, the board split 5-4 on the question of voting electronically to cancel the already over-due election, according to EC board member Bridget Mowat.

 

The organization's bylaws require annual elections.  This year's election was slated to be held in January or February of 2008, when the terms of office for four of the board members expired.  The EC board is required by federal law to have 55% of its members elected to their seats by the general public.  Six residents had announced their candidacies for the each of the vacant seats.

Jet Ski Public Meeting

Thursday, May 8th, 2008

DLNR TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETING ON JET SKI USE AROUND MOLOKAI

HONOLULU – The Department of Land and Natural Resources will hold an informal public meeting on Molokai on Thursday, May 8 from 2 to 3 p.m. at the Mitchell Pauole Community Center conference room to hear from community members regarding the use of jet skis (also known as personal watercraft or PWCs) around Molokai.

“We understand a petition is being circulated on Molokai to demonstrate public support for legalizing jet ski riding,” said Thielen. “The purpose of this public meeting is to hear directly from residents regarding concerns or questions they might have about the use of jet skis in Molokai waters.”

Residents can also provide comments in writing to the Division of Boating and Ocean Recreation, or at subsequent meetings.

Commercial or recreational use of controlled ocean sports equipment, such as jet skis, is currently prohibited around the islands of Molokai and Lana‘i.

“In recent months we have received complaints from island residents about noise and disturbance to reef animals from an increase in illegal jet ski riding in nearshore waters of Molokai,” said Laura H. Thielen, DLNR chairperson. “After our enforcement division officers followed up on these reported cases, we saw a decrease in jet ski use.”

A similar public meeting will be planned for Lana‘i in the near future.

Legalizing jet ski riding would require a change to the administrative rules of the Division of Boating and Ocean Recreation. The process would involve public hearings on a draft rule change, approval by the Board of Land and Natural Resources, review by the Small Business Regulatory Review Board and Department of the Attorney General, and final signature by the Governor, before the new rules can take effect.

In addition, Hawai‘i Administrative Rule Chapter 13-256-16 requires all personal watercraft operators to be certified in the safe use of their watercraft, by completing a class offered through the University of Hawai‘i Community College System.

Under its administrative rules, thrill craft operations may be curtailed in certain designated areas as necessary, to avoid possible adverse impacts on humpback whales or other protected marine life; provide for increased public access; reduce user conflicts; and promote overall public safety.

Any person requiring accommodations for special needs (i.e. sign language interpreter, large print documents, etc.) may contact harbormaster Bernard Strehler at Kaunakakai Harbor (808) 553-1742 to make arrangements for assistance.

“Gift to Landowners”

Tuesday, May 6th, 2008

Controversial Senate Bill 2646 passed the Senate last Thursday in a 14-10 vote. Supporters claim the bill is designed to preserve important agricultural lands and promote agricultural production. But opponents say the bill is a major “Gift to Landowners” that paves the way for development through expedited land reclassification, tax credits, and other incentives.

The bill now awaits the Governor’s approval which would put it into effect in July.

SB 2646 has drawn particular criticism for its reclassification incentive which allows landowners to swap classification of 15% of its acreage from agricultural to urban, rural, or conservation as long as they designate 85% of their acreage to “important-ag.”

A 2008 Senate report states that the bill’s explicit intent is “to create incentives that balance the State's interest and desire for the designation of important-ag with the landowners' need and desire for more development opportunities.”

Molokai Minute – Solatario, Skate Park, and Read Aloud America

Tuesday, May 6th, 2008

Mana`o

Monday, May 5th, 2008

In our continuing series with 'O Hina i ka Malama, the Hawaiian Language Immersion Program at Molokai High School, students play Friendly Isle planners. This is their mana`o on what ideas or creative businesses they believe would best benefit or sustain Molokai.

Ku`uleialoha Kahana-Kalua, 17

Kailana Ritte-Camara, 15

'O kekahi mea makemake makou e kukulu, 'o ia no kekahi kula kaiapuni no na haumana `olelo Hawai'i. He maika`i a `oi aku ka hau`oli, ina loa`a ia makou kekahi kula kaiapuni no makou a me na makua no ho'i!

'O kekahi mea a`e, makemake au e kukulu i kekahi hale a'o, he 'ano kula nui no na po`e i loa'a 'ole i ka hana a me na po`e e pono ai ka hana. Hiki ia lakou ke a'o i kekahi makau hou ma ia hale. A makemake pu au i kekahi hale nui no na keiki i hana`ino 'ia e na makua a me na 'ohana paha. He hale ho'omalu paha no ia.

If I had a chance to be a leader, I would like to build a Hawaiian immersion school for people who want to learn Hawaiian like parents, and for our current Hawaiian immersion students.

I would also like to see a training center that is built for people who need training or want to have training for jobs. I would also like to have a center that helps protect kids that are being abused or hurt in any way.

On the Rise

Monday, May 5th, 2008

Water Working Group nears report completion.

By Brandon Roberts

After lengthy discussion on the future of the Island’s water policy, the Molokai Water Working Group (MWWG) gave a hana hou to complete their initial water report revision at the April 30 meeting. All that remains is to approve and attach the group’s new recommendations for the finalized document due in June.

Creating a special management designation for surface water was a prevailing recommendation to ensure conservation of all Molokai waters. Currently, there is only a special management designation for underground water. The MWWG report will advise the State Commission on Water Resource Management, and eventually be implemented into the County General Plan.

Evaporating Rights

Friday, May 2nd, 2008

-->

Signs Held High

Friday, April 25th, 2008

Signs Held High

Bernie Bicoy held her sign high in the afternoon heat at the April 16 event. It reads hoe imua, or “paddle together.” “We need to support each other to benefit the economic future,” Bicoy said. She was having fun in the sun, “It reminds me of the peaceful demonstrations of the 1960’s.”

Ranch and Monsanto employees team up in a show of solidarity.

By Brandon Roberts

Horns were honking as 80 Molokai Ranch and Monsanto employees proudly waved their mana`o, holding signs street side at Kulana O`iwi. They are hoping the “Rally for Change” event will get across a positive message, as well as create hope for change.

Many in the event are directly affected by the Molokai Ranch shutdown, which cut around 120 jobs in March.

“This is peaceful, and we want to be heard with what we want for our island,” rallier Linda DeMello said, displaying her message that we are all human.

“This is what family is all about. I am here to support the children and grandchildren,” said Janice Pele, a Maunaloa kupuna. She is keiki o ka `aina, a mother of 12 and grandmother to many more. She said she supports Molokai Ranch’s Master Plan to develop La`au Point.

Auny Maile Pidot is the po`o (head) of the Maunaloa kupuna, and has been there most her life. She has lived through the coming and going of the pineapple plantations, the Kaluakoi Sheraton Resort, and multiple Molokai Ranch owners.

“I have seen hard times,” she said. “I want to be here for the employees, we are all ohana.” Aunty Pidot did more than just talk, as she participating in the La`au planning process. “La`au and the Plan can be done and still be culturally preserving and respectful.”

“Everybody should work together and not fight off the big companies, but find solutions,” said Maka, a Monsanto employee. “We cannot be Hawaiians fighting Hawaiians.” He cheered as cars went by saying he is here to “show support for the sisters and brothers.”

Coupled with solidarity is an underlying nervousness amongst the Monsanto participants, a fear that the “activists” have their sights on Monsanto. “We are standing up before it happens to us,” said one Monsanto employee.

“If we lose Monsanto, we lose millions of dollars in revenue to this island,” Maka said. “We have got to have jobs. We are the foundation for these companies.”

Monsanto is now the largest private corporation on Molokai, employing around 100 full-time and 50 seasonal workers. The bio-tech company is not without controversy; growing hundreds of acres of genetically-engineered corn on the island, which has many concerned.

In a recent meeting with Monsanto Molokai general manger Ray Foster and community affairs manager Paul Koehler, the two stated they did not see an impact from the Ranch closure to their 99 year land lease with the Ranch. They also said they were not pursuing land acquisitions from the Ranch.

“We have no current plans for expansion, but it is not out of the question,” said Foster.

Monsanto currently leases 1,800 acres from Molokai Ranch, with only 400 of those acres planted, and the rest used as a buffer-zone between plantings. They are currently updating their drying facility, a project which should be finalized in May.

According to annual reports, Monsanto spends around $8 million a year on Molokai, and $144 million State-wide. Across the islands, they have 4,820 acres and employ over 2,000.

What’s Blowin On

Thursday, April 24th, 2008

What’s Blowin On

Here is a rendering of what the UPC wind farm would look like on Molokai.

Community forum hosts talks about Molokai wind-farm.

By Brandon Roberts

Renewable energy is a Hawaiian value in that it aims at harnessing the gift of nature without depleting it. But is the greater community willing to tap Molokai’s steady wind resources at the sacrifice of building a large scale wind farm?

For the past several weeks, it has been the mission of Molokai youth to gauge the community’s acceptance of the potential wind farm. Forums have already been held in Kilohana, Kaunakakai, Ho`olehua and Maunaloa.

“Ask the hard questions,” youth organizer Matt Yamashita told community members. “What vision are we going to put forth to create a future that fits with what we believe the potential of this island is. We are not representing UPC; we just created the space to have this dialogue.”

Numerous concerns surround this development proposal, and Molokai asked the crucial question: Are there benefits to the community?

Will UPC Hawaii Wind bring jobs to folks on the Friendly Isle? UPC says maybe for the construction, but only a skeleton crew is required for the remaining 20 years. (They did agree to sign a contract not use potable water from the island during construction.)

Will UPC lower electricity rates on Molokai? No guarantee. There are many problems with hooking a variable source, like wind, up to the current diesel plant, and the proposal is a one-way cable to Oahu for Hawaiian Electric Company (HECO).

“There are some big ‘ifs’ with this project; one is gaining control of the lands, second is the undersea cable and third is whether our bid to HECO would be accepted,” said Wren Wescoatt, development specialist.

Would the project prevent access to the land for hunting or recreation? According to UPC, the project would prevent other types of development on thousands of acres while providing a source of community revenue. Pre-existing uses of the land would continue once the construction was completed. At the end of the lease, the windmills would be completely removed.

Can a deal be struck quickly between UPC and Guoco Leisure? There is no guarantee, and UPC has been in discussions since 2006.

How will money come back to the community? UPC has committed $50 million toward Ho`i I Ka Pono (to restore righteousness or balance), a campaign led by the Molokai Community Service Council (MCSC) to purchase all of the lands now owned by Molokai Ranch. UPC would lease the land from MCSC, which could amount to five million dollars per year.

How close would the windmill be to a home? No turbine would be constructed within a half mile of residencies, and the Liberty units have an extremely low noise output, rotating at 21 times per minute, though they are a skyscraping 400 feet tall.

Representative Mele Carroll said that it is “brilliant that young people are doing this; it is creating leaders.” She met with UPC planners earlier and said that the company has many potential opportunities for Molokai.

“UPC combines technology with Molokai island values,” said Noe Kalipi, UPC director of community relations. Statistically speaking, one mega-watt (MW) hour of energy saves 17,000 lbs of carbon dioxide. The power plant on Molokai burns around one million gallons of diesel fuel every year.

Kalipi said there is a seriousness and legitimacy to this project. “We want to have transparency, which is fluid, we want to establish and ongoing dialogue. UPC is a community conscious and a community based company.” UPC began meeting with Molokai leaders in 2006.

The proposed Ikaika (energy) project is under discussion with Molokai homesteaders and the Department of Hawaiian Homelands, and would use 20 windmills and produce 50 MW. Ikaika II, which would be on 12,000 acres spanning between Ho`olehua and Ilio Point on Molokai’s rugged northwestern coast line. Both projects could produce a combined 350 MW.

Castle and Cook, which is owned by David Murdock, has a wind-farm project that is moving ahead on Lanai, despite failed legislation to fast track the project. They will submit a bid to HECO as well.

“UPC has an incentive to do things right, as we are accountable to the communities we join for the life of our project,” Kalipi said, emphasizing the UPC mission.

“We are creating a future for this island,” said Matt Yamashita, holding onto the idea of finding a common ground.

“We have within us the will, the mana, the smarts, and the commitment to create something we can all be happy with,” said Akutagawa. “And then the scars in our heart will heal, and we can look at each other and say aloha.”

Any questions regarding the community forums can be directed to molokaisolutions@yahoo.com. Information on UPC Wind can be found at www.upcwind.com, and the Molokai Community Service Council can be reached at www.molokai.org.

Changing of the Guard

Wednesday, April 16th, 2008

Changing of the Guard

New planning commissioners welcomed.

By Brandon Roberts

It is a new era at the Molokai Planning Commission (MoPC) with the introduction of two new commissioners, as well as the election of a new chairman and vice-chair.

Steve Chaikin was unanimously voted in as the new commission chair. To his right, Miki`ala Pescaia was voted in as the new vice-chairwoman.

“We can either be proactive or reactive,” said Chair Chaikin in his first address to the commission.

Lori Buchanan and Don Williams were introduced at the April 9 meeting in the Mitchell Pau`ole Center. These new commissioners were appointed by Mayor Charmaine Tavares, and approved by the Maui County Council.

Councilman Danny Mateo made a point to talk story with the incoming commissioners. He had this to say about them, “Lori has the time to commit and Don is a businessman, and brings perspective,” he said. “I think the two coming on-board are a good balance.”

Williams submitted an application for appointment “primarily because I thought the commission needed someone that was in the development world to assist in the decision making.” He added that some of his strengths are hands-on experience, and real-world knowledge.

A contractor on Molokai for 15 years, Williams has been in the construction business over 40 years. He grew up on Big Island and moved to the Friendly Isle from Oahu. “I have seen what uninhibited over-development can lead to,” referring to his time on Oahu.

He says he is dedicated to the commission and represents the West End. One of his main concerns is with illegal development, and he would like to see it corrected. “There are proper ways to do business.”

Buchanan, a wahine who wears many hats on Molokai, is a former councilmember and was chairwoman for two of her five year term. She also works with the Nature Conservancy, specializing with invasive species. She waited the mandatory two years before reapplying for the MoPC.

She is keiki o ka `aina, born in Ho`olehua, and now resides in Kalae. She brings experience and familiarity with Maui County codes and regulations to the commission.

Buchanan resubmitted an application to “serve the community in the best possible way.” She said she “cares about the island and what happens to it.”

The MoPC is a diverse group of Friendly Isle residents who volunteere their service to oversee, regulate, and shape the development of the last Hawaiian island.

The MoPC will host its next meeting April 23 at 12:30 p.m. in the Mitchell Pau`ole Center.