Political

Molokai and Hawaii – Island Politics

Schatz Discusses Molokai’s Strengths, Challenges

Wednesday, July 20th, 2011

Schatz Discusses Molokai’s Strengths, Challenges

Lt. Governor Brian Schatz visited Molokai last Wednesday, attending an award ceremony honoring Monsanto Hawaii’s Molokai farm for receiving the U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration’s top safety designation. He also visited several Molokai businesses and organizations before sitting down with The Molokai Dispatch for a question and answer session.

TMD: How has office been so far for you?


SCHATZ:  We’ve been making good progress. I think it’s important to remember how far we’ve come in the last seven months. We started with a $1.3 billion budget shortfall and not a lot of economic momentum. By the end of the year, we expect to have a balanced financial plan and we’re gonna see some improvement in the private economy as well. We understand that there are special challenges on Molokai and that’s one of the reasons that I’m here on behalf of the governor, is to better understand how state government can help folks and try to create jobs.

the public utilities commission to decide upon together, hopefully by consensus. The truth is Oahu is not in a position to generate its own energy, there’s not enough land, and so Molokai has an opportunity to benefit from the fact that they can provide electricity to Oahu. So it’s just a matter of configuring an arrangement so that Molokai gets its fair share.

TMD: Should the community stay so opposed to Big Wind, and their mind isn’t changed, do you still think this is the right path?

SCHATZ: I think it depends on how you define community. It’s very early in the process, and I’m confident that we can find ways to make renewable energy work and still have respect for and appreciation for the places where the energy gets generated. So I don’t want to get through a hypothetical about well what if it doesn’t work out, because I think that would be a couple of years from now, but I really do think there are models that work. For instance, with Puna on the Big Island, geothermal, there was strong opposition to that and now because the model has changed, you have many of the same people who were opposed to the project asking for additional wells and additional geothermal energy. Why is that? Because their opposition in the ’70s wasn’t about being opposed to geothermal energy, it was about a sense that it wasn’t fair. And so if you do these things in a way that’s fair, then you can get maybe not everyone unanimously in favor of something, but you can get some degree of consensus. And I think as long as you’re respectful and fair, that’s the right way to do things.

TMD: We just wanted to talk a little bit about agriculture. How do you think Molokai can contribute more agriculturally to the state?

SCHATZ: I think there are a lot of people who want to farm. One of the challenges on Molokai is water, and I think our Department of Hawaiian Homelands and our Department of Agriculture are working to try to make sure that those who want to farm have water that’s available and affordable. So that’s the government’s job. The government’s job is to set the table, set the stage for agriculture to occur. We can’t force anybody to farm or anybody to buy a product from a farm, but what we can do is provide training, provide technical expertise. We can do a little bit in the area of creating markets through the Department of Education, through our prison system. There’s a strong desire to make sure that if we’re buying food for our own prisoners and certainly for our own keiki that it ought to be as much as possible local food. And that would be to create a built-in market, and that all takes time. So we’re working on those issues. If we can create a market and allow people’s land to have access to water, that’s real progress.

Community Denounces District Voting

Monday, July 18th, 2011

“If it’s not broken, don’t fix it.” That was the message Molokai residents gave members of the Maui Charter Commission last week, when more than a dozen community members testified against proposed changes to the Maui County Charter. Charter proposals include instituting a district voting system to elect the Maui County Council, which could take away a Molokai resident’s seat.

The Charter Commission, an 11-member board nominated by the Mayor and approved by the Maui County Council, is formed once a decade to review the Maui County Charter. Amendments proposed by the Commission are placed on the 2012 ballot for voters to decide.

PUC: HECO must seek new energy bids

Friday, July 15th, 2011

To read the updated version of this story published on TheMolokaiDispatch.com on July 17, click here.

--

The Public Utilities Commission (PUC) ordered on Thursday that Hawaiian Electric Company (HECO) restart the bidding process for a 200 megawatt (MW) wind farm proposed for Molokai.

This means wind company Pattern Energy, that has been in discussions with the community and land owner Molokai Ranch, may re-enter the bidding process for the project, along with any other company that wishes to propose a similar project.

Veterans’ Lawsuit Inches Forward

Monday, July 11th, 2011

Molokai Veterans Caring for Veterans’ (MVCV) lawsuit against the County of Maui is still moving forward, according to a federal judge’s order last week. The judge heard further amendments to the veterans’ complaints, allowing some to remain in the case, while others were denied.

“It’s not a decision, but a step forward for the veterans,” said the group’s attorney Suki Halevi.

The date for the jury trial has also been set back to March 28, 2012 from the original date scheduled for this October.

Molokai Commission to Vote on Short Term Rentals

Saturday, July 2nd, 2011

Molokai continues to teeter on the balance between the economic benefits from tourism and the desire to maintain the island’s pristine and undeveloped flavor. The Molokai Planning Commission (MoPC) is in the process of addressing whether or not to approve a legal avenue for homeowners wishing to turn their home into a short term rental, also known as a transient vacation rental (TVR).

At their meeting last week, commissioners debated on a draft ordinance from the Maui County Council that would establish permitting procedures for short-term rental homes on Molokai, Lanai and Maui.

Budget Cuts Hit Education Again

Sunday, June 26th, 2011

While school furlough days ended last year, education budget woes are not over. The Department of Education (DOE) is facing a $32.8 million budget reduction over the next two fiscal years. As part of the cuts, the DOE made adjustments to the weighted student formula, or per-pupil funding, as well as redefined the student enrollment required to be considered a small school. Sixty-four campuses around the state, including all schools on Molokai, will lose money as a result of the small school redefinition, according to DOE Budget Specialist Brian Hallett.

Molokai Group Unites Against Industrial Wind

Monday, June 6th, 2011

Molokai Group Unites Against Industrial Wind

A group of Molokai residents have banded together in hopes that a proposed wind farm on the island will blow away. The mission of I Aloha Molokai, or IAM, is to educate fellow residents about, and organize opposition to, plans for wind turbines on Molokai and an undersea cable that would carry that energy to serve Oahu’s energy needs. 

They began those efforts publicly by inviting Robin Kaye of Friends of Lanai (FOL) – a group already vocally opposed to a similar project on Lanai – to speak on Molokai last week.

“There was an overwhelming 'no' from the people of Molokai [to industrial wind energy on the island],” said one of IAM’s organizer, Kanoho Helm. He was referring to a recent island-wide survey conducted by the `Aha Ki`ole, in which 93 percent of residents were opposed to a wind farm.

Meanwhile, wind company Pattern Energy continues to move forward in negotiations with Molokai Ranch and discussion with Molokai community members to build a proposed 200 megawatt (MW) wind farm on the island’s west end.

Strength in Numbers

to ratepayers,” according to Kaye. The bill did not pass in the past executive session, but received significant support from both the state House and the Senate.

The bill would have established a regulatory structure for installation and cost of the interisland electric transmission cable that would be built between Molokai, Lanai, Maui and Oahu. The bill authorized collection of a cable surcharge that would be assessed to ratepayers to reimburse the company building the cable for construction costs.

In addition, a “rate adjustment” would be authorized on ratepayers to cover the utility company’s investment in the cable and on-island infrastructure.

Kaye urged residents to write to Rep. Mele Carroll and Sen. Kalani English in opposition to SB 367.

“Leaders think that people on neighbor islands are stupid,” he said. “I think it would be incredibly powerful to say, 'these two islands say ‘no.’'”

Cost of Wind Energy
Mike Bond, Molokai resident and former CEO of an international energy company, shared with residents just how much he believes wind turbines could cost the community.

“Wind towers are astonishingly expensive and stunningly inefficient,” he said of the proposed 400-foot turbines.

He estimated property values between Kaunakakai and Maunaloa would drop about 25 percent during construction of the turbines, and about 15 percent in the long run. He painted a vivid picture of the thousands of concrete trucks rolling down the highway carrying materials for the massive turbine foundations. He calculated it would take about 400 truckloads of concrete per windmill base.

Once the turbines are constructed, Bond said their design and fluctuation of energy produced is so inefficient that only about 16 MW out of the proposed 200 MW project would actually be available to send to Oahu. That means only about 1 percent of Oahu’s energy consumption would be supplied by Molokai’s wind farm, according to Bond.

“The whole thing is a hokey scam – it makes no sense financially,” he concluded. “It is not pono to sell Molokai.”

West end resident Bob Underwood agreed. “I’m not against it, but they better have a good reason before they disturb my refuge,” he said.

Molokai resident Frank Leary has built many of his own wind generation systems, and shared his observations.

“Half the time of each year, wind generators – no matter what size – won’t work here because there’s not enough wind,” he said.

In addition, Leary explained that because wind provides such an inconsistent source of energy, back-up generators would still be needed.

“It’s not dependence from oil,” he said. “That ain’t going green a bit.”

Stay tuned for more community meetings held by IAM. Pattern Energy will be also holding informational meetings in the month of June: June 21 at the Maunaloa Community Center, 5:30 – 7 p.m.; June 22    at the Mitchell Pauole Center, 6 – 7:30 p.m.; June 23 at Kilohana School, 6 – 7:30 p.m.

Health Center Moves Ahead

Monday, May 16th, 2011

After delays in the transformation of the old Pau Hana Inn into the new Molokai Community Health Center (MCHC), the organization received the second installment of state funds last week that will allow them to complete phase one of renovations. The MCHC also received a Special Area Management (SMA) permit from the Molokai Planning Commission (MoPC) last Wednesday – a green light for the second phase of construction.

Renovation work was halted in the first phase of its construction after delays in the release of $1 million in state funds allocated for the project. Desiree Puhi, executive director of MCHC, said it will take about a year to complete the second phase.

Total cost of the project is about $6.5 million.

Hope for Cheaper Kalaupapa Flights

Monday, May 16th, 2011

After two years of struggling under exorbitant airfares into Kalaupapa, there may be light at the end of the tunnel for patients and workers. Department of Transportation (DOT) officials are working with the Kalaupapa community to help a second air service offer flights to the peninsula.  Residents will be giving their mana`o on which of the three companies that have applied for subsidies will be awarded the funding.

Patients and workers in Kalaupapa saw a glimpse of hope when Sen. Dan Inouye brought the Secretary of the DOT Ray LaHood to Honolulu on March 25 to introduce him to Kalaupapa patients and hear their woes over high airfares.

Commissioner Nomination Contested

Monday, May 2nd, 2011

The Molokai Planning Commission (MoPC) has one open seat and it could be filled by early June by Oliver “DeGray” Vanderbilt.  But his nomination by Mayor Alan Arakawa has been under review for the past two weeks after several Molokai community members have questioned his residency status.

Arakawa nominated Vanderbilt in April to fill the seat previously filled by Napua Leong, who resigned from the commission in December 2010. The commission has a maximum of nine seats, and eight out of them have been filled. Vanderbilt already served on the MoPC from 2003-2008, and was chairman his last year.