La`au Point

Mayor Tavares And Molokai Council Member Mateo Respond To Ranch Closure

Tuesday, March 25th, 2008

Mayor Charmaine Tavares and Molokai Council Member Danny A. Mateo comments on today’s announcement by Molokai Properties that the company will be shutting down a majority of its operations effective April 5, 2008.

Mayor Tavares:

“The impact on the community will be quite serious. I’m concerned for the employees and families that are affected. This is devastating news and they will be the ones who will feel it the most.

While I have great faith in the tenacity and resiliency of the people of Molokai, I am concerned about their economic future.

For an island that has the state’s highest unemployment rate, this adds to an already stressful employment situation. We’ll be looking for ways that the county, state and non-profit community can provide support to the workers and their families. My staff has been informed that the state’s Workforce Development Division and the state Unemployment Insurance Office are expected to send a rapid response team to Molokai in the next few days to meet with the affected employees.

Lingle Focuses On Molokai Ranch Employees, Island’s Economy

Tuesday, March 25th, 2008

Lingle Focuses On Molokai Ranch Employees, Island’s Economy

HONOLULU – Governor Linda Lingle today outlined steps the State Administration is taking to assist 120 displaced workers on Moloka‘i following the announcement by Moloka‘i Ranch that it will cease its operations at the end of this month.  

 

“My immediate concern is for the 120 employees and their families who will be affected by this closure,” said Governor Lingle.  “My office and several state departments are working together to assist the employees in the short-term, while minimizing the long-term economic impact.

 

“Because of Moloka‘i’s small population, the closure of one of the island’s largest private employers will have a disproportionate impact on the island’s economy,” said the Governor.  “The loss of this many jobs in such a small community like Moloka‘i is equivalent to 23,000 people on O‘ahu losing their jobs on the same day.”

 

“It is unfortunate that after working with the community and state and local government on developing its master plan for so long, Moloka‘i Ranch is unable to continue its operations,” said Governor Lingle. The company has stated that its net loss from 2001 to 2006 has been approximately $37 million.  “Through all of this, the employees worked hard and made sacrifices.  We want to do everything we can to help the employees and the Moloka‘i community.”

 

On Thursday, state officials will travel to Moloka‘i to meet with the employees to provide information on what type of assistance is available.  The Department of Labor and Industrial Relations’ (DLIR) Rapid Response Team, accompanied by officials from the Department of Human Services (DHS), will hold two meetings, at 10:00 a.m. and 1:00 p.m., to provide employees with information on unemployment insurance, job training and placement and medical benefits.  The meetings will take place at the Moanaloa Tri-Plex theatre.

 

DLIR Director Darwin Ching will lead the meeting, which will also include presentations by the administrator of the Unemployment Insurance Division who will explain the process and timeline for filing claims, as well as the administrator of the Workforce Development Division.  Branch managers of the Maui Unemployment Insurance and Workforce Development divisions, as well as staff from DLIR’s Moloka‘i office will also be on hand to assist the employees.

In addition, representatives from the DHS will provide information and help employees determine if and when they are eligible for medical benefits, including QUEST, QUEST Ace and Medicaid.  

 

Over the next few weeks, the Rapid Response Team will survey workers to evaluate their job skills and determine how many people need training and what type of job placement assistance is required.  Officials are also reaching out to businesses on Maui and Moloka‘i to identify potential job opportunities for workers who are willing to move or commute.  The team will also work with the Department of Human Services First-to-Work office on Moloka‘i to provide direct employment assistance and the support services necessary to find employment.

Governor Lingle also announced she would convene a Moloka‘i Action Team, comprised of state, county and community representatives to identify additional opportunities to assist the displaced workers in the short-term, while also focusing on ways to rebuild the island’s workforce base.  

Molokai Ranch Shutting Down

Monday, March 24th, 2008

Molokai Ranch to Layoff 120 Employees 

Molokai Properties Limited is to shutdown its operations on Molokai at the end of March.

The Company will lay-off more than 120 staff on the island over the following 60 days.

Company CEO Peter Nicholas said that staff had been advised of the company’s position at employee meetings on Molokai and in Honolulu today.

He said that MPL (better known as Molokai Ranch) intends to “mothball” the company’s assets on its 60,000+ acre property on Molokai.

“The decision is purely a business one,” said Mr. Nicholas.

“For the past five years MPL has been working with Molokai community leaders and community members on developing and implementing a Master Plan for MPL’s property and the future of Molokai.

“Unacceptable delays caused by continued opposition to every aspect of the Master Plan means we are unable to fund continued normal company operations,” he said.

Operations to be shut will be the Molokai Lodge, the Kaupoa Beach Village, the Kaluakoi Golf Course, the Maunaloa gas station, the Maunaloa Tri-Flex theatre, cattle-rearing, and the company’s substantial maintenance
operations.

As well as shutting these operations, MPL will close all access to its property indefinitely, said Mr. Nicholas.
“We deeply regret to have taken this step as the main impact will be on our loyal employees,” he said.

“This will also be a bitter blow to Plan supporters, whose main interests in supporting the Master Plan have been a sustained economic future for Molokai.

“However, as we have mentioned on many occasions, without the prospect of an economic future for the company that results from the implementation of all facets of the Master Plan, we are unable to continue to bear large losses from continuing these operations,” he said.

Culture Shock

Monday, March 10th, 2008

Molokai Ranch terminates its Hawaiian cultural program.


 

By Brandon Roberts

At Kaupoa Beach, in West Molokai, there is a sacred garden named Na Piko, where culture was cultivated alongside indigenous plants. It is there that the mo`olelo of Molokai had been shared with many by Anakala Pilipo Solatario, a man who dedicates his life to perpetuating Hawaiian culture.

Solatario, the man who created Na Piko, doesn’t enter the garden anymore. The grounds are leo`ole – stories are no longer told. Solatario will not set foot in the sanctuary until it is closed with proper Hawaiian ceremony.

On Feb. 23, Solatario gave his final protocol as Molokai Ranch’s Cultural Director; his position, along with the Ranch’s cultural program, was terminated.

“The Ranch has always spoken of how important Hawaiian culture is,” Solatario said, expressing his disappointment. “Now, all of the sudden, there is no need for culture.”

The Ranch did not give Solatario a written notification; neither did ILWU local 142, the union representing the employees. After almost 30 years working for the Ranch, Solatario received a phone call from human resources telling him the news.

However, Solatario was not fired; the union offered him a different position at a lower wage. If Solatario decides to quit, he would lose severance pay and unemployment benefits.

“What does this show the community about respect for the culture?” Solatario asks.

Solatario is a kumu (teacher) of Hawaiian culture. His position as Cultural Director at the Ranch developed in 1996 due to his knowledge, commitment, and respect of indigenous practices.

In 2005, Solatario, nominated by Molokai Ranch, was awarded the annual Kahili Award. Presented by fellow cultural kumu and the Hawaii Tourism Authority, the statewide award honors individuals who have devoted their lives to teaching and sharing Hawaiian culture.

A former Ranch employee and colleague of Solatario, Julie Ann-Bicoy calls him the kupuna of culture. “He played a major role in educating visitors and locals on our culture,” she said.

“It is significant that locals understand where they come from and be able to share the culture,” Ann-Bicoy said. “He was able to create a cohesive understanding.”

“If they (Molokai Ranch) understood the culture, they would not have gotten rid of it,” Ann-Bicoy said. “For an island of Hawaiian culture, where does this leave the Ranch?”

Since 2001, the Ranch has lost more than $30 million in operating costs, and another $30 million in capital expenditures and upkeep. The losses have been subsidized by the Ranch’s parent company, Guoco Group Limited.

For several years, Guoco has been trying to develop a 200-lot millionaire’s subdivision in a culturally significant area known as La`au Point in West Molokai. John Sabas, the Ranch’s general manager, said in the past that the company would be forced to cut back on operations if the La`au project is unsuccessful.

“This is not a cutback, it’s a termination,” Solatario said. “If Molokai Ranch cannot find a financial benefit to the culture, they get rid of it.”

Molokai Ranch has held several employee meetings to gather support for the La’au development. “The Ranch is throwing palu (chum), but not all fish will bite,” Solatario said. In a recent secret ballot, 10 out of 18 employees voted against support for the development.

Solatario suspects his position against the development may be the reason for his termination. However, he says he does not regret his actions.

“What I am saying is true, it is pono,” Solatario said.

Several phone calls and emails to Sabas regarding Solatario’s termination were not returned.

The piko of Molokai Ranch was Solatario’s cultural program. For visitors, it brought about awareness and respect for Molokai ways. In the wake of the Ranch’s choice, there remains emptiness in the absence of Hawaiian culture.

Guoco’s Stewardship of Dilapidated Property Raises Red Flags

Thursday, March 6th, 2008

After many trips to the Islands of Hawaii over the last 20 years, my wife and I had the great pleasure of visiting Molokai.  What a wonderful place!  Beautiful scenery, friendly people, abundant wild life, and most of all, a quiet laid back lifestyle.  Unfortunately, there is trouble in paradise.  As a person that is not privy to all the facts about the battle between the people of Molokai and Guoco Leisure Limited (GLL), it looks like it could get ugly and do lasting damage to Molokai.  At issue is granting MPL the right to sell property to build 200 homes at La`au Point .  As evidenced by the numerous signs with the theme "Save La`au" there is virtually no support from locals to approve the MPL proposal.

Missing the point in “Lā‘au Satire”

Sunday, February 10th, 2008

In reading Alona Demmers’s recent review of my satire on L?‘au, I was really surprised that despite her obvious literary capacity, she was unable to recognize the motive or purpose behind this satire. It appears that because of her own insecurities, she has misconstrued the content of the satire and turned it into something personal. I readily admit that “bullets flying through the air as your children return home from school” is a legitimate concern, but it was never the intent of my letter to somehow endorse that type of situation as something that is acceptable.

My intention was, in Alona’s own words, to expose the “human folly” in attempting to develop and construct residential homes in a place that is (1) a traditional hunting area; (2) an area where the majority of the island opposes development; (3) an area that lacks adequate water; (4) an area that is a critical environmental and cultural habitat. My intention was also to expose the folly of the Molokai EC. Though this organization is supposed to represent the community, the majority vote of this group has continuously ignored public sentiment to the point now of not even allowing the people of Molokai to attend it’s meetings.

In regard to using the word “outsider” I was simply referring to someone coming from outside of Molokai. In Molokai Ranch’s Environmental Impact Study for La’au Point, the Ranch clearly states in their financial report that they expect potential buyers to be penta- millionaires coming from “outside” of Molokai. An interesting item of note is that they expect a fair percentage of those buyers to be those who come from other resort areas of Hawaii and who have in turn grown dissatisfied with the areas they now live in because of the exponential growth that has taken place in those areas.  As far as whether or not someone fits into Molokai, well, Molokai herself has a way of figuring that one out.

And as far as insect phobia goes, I am afraid that this is one of the side effects of our modern society, where we end up spending much more time behind computer and TV screens than spending time outdoors, experiencing the wonders of the natural world (including insects). The good news for those who have been raised in such a disconnected manner is that Molokai offers the opportunity to reconnect and awards us the privilege to experience and appreciate what only God himself is capable of creating. 

May the desire to protect this special place be a part of our “collective consciousness.”

Mahalo,

Steve  Morgan

Two Thumbs Down for Steve Morgan’s Satire

Monday, February 4th, 2008


By Alona Demmers 

When a writer pens his thoughts on paper, whether it’s the plot for an adventure movie or a witty satirical article for the local paper, one can assume that there is a purpose or a motive behind the effort. After all, why would someone spend all that time formulating ideas on a subject and then typing it in the computer knowing all this hard work is purposeless and futile.  

With this in mind and being someone who enjoys a “good” satire (given my sometimes wicked sense of humor), I jumped at  reading  Steve Morgan’s satirical article “La’au: The Movie, only to find it  short of amusing and without legitimate motive. Aside from perhaps a boost to the writer’s ego (if that’s legitimate enough), hard as I try, I could not convince myself that there was a valid, corrective reason for why this article came to be or should even exist , not to mention, published. A satire exposes human folly and vice to ridicule with the intent to inspire social reform.  Perhaps I need someone to enlighten me since the only motive I could scrape from this article in its simplest form is ill spirited and in its most productive form inciting intolerance  and  discord .  I would venture to say that even the most positive person out there will fail to squeeze an ounce of inspiration for social reform from the aforementioned satire.

Responding to the Draft EIS

Tuesday, January 29th, 2008

Comment period open to public

With a new year and a new Draft Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for the proposed La`au Point development, now is the time to get involved. Molokai Properties Limited (MPL) will be accepting comments on the Draft EIS until Feb. 22.

MPL is required to obtain an EIS in order to move ahead with the proposed La`au Point development. However, the process requires that the company addresses community concerns first.

The 45-day comment period, which began on Jan. 8, is a way for the community to get involved. After Feb. 22, MPL will review and respond to the comments. They are required to include these comments in the Final EIS document.

La`au Point a No-Brainer

Wednesday, January 23rd, 2008

Molokai Ranch's John Sabas was recently quoted in the Maui News stating that supporting the La'au Point development on Molokai is a "no-brainer." 

Ahh, that explains a lot: According to this quote, the executives of Molokai Ranch, and others who support this development, (apparently) have no brains! (Or, at least, are choosing NOT to use the ones they have.) 

Thank goodness the rest of us opposing the development are actually using ours to think critically and carefully about this issue. In doing, we recognize that building 200 luxury estates for "pentamillionaires," in a  sacred and pristine area, on an island that has critical unresolved water issues, as well as a unique lifestyle her people hope to maintain, is simply not a good idea. (No matter how much of their land Molokai Ranch offers to give inexchange.) 

New EIS an Improvement

Thursday, January 17th, 2008

A satirical look at the proposed La`au development.

Well any one who thought that there would be no improvements with Molokai Ranch’s new EIS is totally wrong. The font style used on the front cover of the EIS is absolutely beautiful and displays a distinct style that is both inspiring and thoughtful.  

In regard to the EIS I have a suggestion that could really work if implemented. I was reflecting on an old science fiction movie the other night called “Silent Running”. Not sure if anyone remembers this flick or not but in the movie the last bit of ecological habitat left in the universe is concealed in what appears to be a giant plexi glass dome.

But here’s my thought, rather than put the area of ecological habitat inside the dome, we put the development inside. Think of it, the La’au development could be inside a giant plexi glass dome. You might ask what are the advantages 1) Those who live in the dome would be totally isolated from the rest of the community and wouldn’t have to deal with insults or bad vibes (2) the dome would conceal unwanted noise from encroaching hunters and shield from the occasional stray bullet (3) Phobic mainlanders and outsiders who can’t handle insects and wild life could live in a remarkably clean and antiseptic environment (4) With no available water for La’au, a plexi glass dome could work something like a giant green house collecting moisture on it’s walls. (5) Plexi glass is transparent and still offers outstanding views. This is extremely important when taking real estate values into consideration. 

There are certain complexities that would have to be dealt with such as bird kukae collecting on the upper portion of the dome but this issue could be easily dealt with. In fact, with the EC board no longer having to be pestered by the community, it is possible that this board could take the time necessary to plan and strategize such a design.  I am exited as we reach out to protect the people who will live at La’au and help to prosper those who will benefit from such a project. 

Mahalo,Steve Morgan