Letters

Dispatch Editor submits comment on Molokai Ranch’s proposed development of La`au Point

Friday, February 23rd, 2007

- edited 3/12/07 

Finally, in section 4.2.4 of the DEIS, facilitator Davianna McGregor’s own findings support the fact that residents are not for the plan: “In general, of those people that were interviewed for the cultural impact assessment and those who came to cultural assessment community meetings, many expressed reservations about the proposed development. There were no enthusiastic advocates and the most vocal were opposed to the development.” 

There is overwhelming proof that the Molokai Community does not support the development of La`au Point. Both MPL CEO, Peter Nicholas, and Public Relations Manager, John Sabas, need to stay true to their promises to the Molokai people and rethink their plans for La`au Point. Todd Yamashita – Molokai Dispatch Editor in Chief

Comments on Molokai Ranch’s Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) were due today. The DEIS outlines possible environmental, social and cultural issues associated with the ranch’s proposed development of La`au Point.  

The comments will be included and addressed in the final impact statement which Molokai Ranch will submit to the State Land Use Commission (LUC). Depending on the accuracy and depth of document, the LUC will either decide for or against changing designation of the La`au project area from agriculture to rural. 

Something Has to Give, Timmy

Wednesday, February 21st, 2007

Hardaway’s homophobic comments self-oppressive, yet reflect the need for change

As his decidedly anti-amourus caveman-like comments on Valentines Day might suggest, it is possible that Tim Hardaway really has been living under a rock for a few years.

Days after former NBA player John Amaechi (left) came out of the closet right before the release of his new book Man In The Middle, retired Miami Heat guard Tim Hardaway sounded off with the following comments when asked how he would have reacted to having a gay teammate: “I hate gay people, so I let it be known. I don't like gay people and I don't like to be around gay people. I am homophobic. I don't like it. It shouldn't be in the world or in the United States.”

Hardaway made the comments while a phone-in guest on host Dan LeBatard’s Miami radio show. At the time, the 5-time all-star was in Las Vegas working with NBA Cares, a community-outreach program which works with various groups like Read to Achieve, Habitat for Humanity, the Make-A-Wish Foundation, and the Global Business Coalition on HIV/AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria(GBC). Hardaway was a five-time all-star, one of the decade’s best point guards in the 1990’s, and played for team USA. He also had a history of philanthropy; for many years Hardaway would donate $20 to cancer research for every assist he racked up in the NBA (Hardaway is 12th on the NBA’s all-time assist leaders list).

It is sad to see a once-great athlete, a hero to many kids especially in the African American community, shoot himself in the foot and ruin any career he may have had in the public eye because of his small-minded, bigoted personal views. Even sadder perhaps, is that it is likely that Hardaway’s views are not altogether rare in professional sports.

Last week, Amaechi himself wrote in ESPN Magazine that “Homophobia is a ballplayer posture, akin to donning a ‘game face’, wearing flashy jewelry or driving the perfect black Escalade.” A well spoken, intelligent athlete, Ameachi arrived at the conclusion that ‘ballers’ didn’t really hate gays, but rather used ‘gaybashing’ as a sort of crutch to empower their ideal of masculinity. One has to wonder, though, how easy it would be to tell the difference were Amaechi out of the closet while still in that small league community.

A member of the Molokai gay community was kind enough to stop by and reflect on the dynamic of homophobia in a small populous. “That basketball player is just an idiot, and I don’t worry about people like that. I think a good rule for everyone to live by is that you don’t need to like everyone, but every person is entitles to a certain amount of respect.

“We’re very lucky because there’s never really been a serious problem here. On Molokai, people are very easy going at work, and in the neighborhoods, with a few small exceptions. Like, you might not see a lot of openly gay hunters, and a few years ago, there was a Mahu show on Halloween, which is always a lot of fun, that was picketed by members of First Assembly Church. But overall, people here don’t get bothered, and that’s a very good thing.”

Some good may come of Hardaway's comments; hopefully, people's curiosity will be piqued and they will read Amaechi’s book. Man in the Middle is a thoughtful and forthright retrospective about being in an oppressive environment. It’s reading by a wide audience may provoke a debate in the population at large about facing homophobic issues in professional sports, an issue that has too long been ignored.


Reflection on ‘A Road Less Taken’:

Tuesday, February 20th, 2007

Profile of Walter Ritte in Hana Hou Magazine Shows Activist’s Sensitive Side to the Outside World


It is safe to say that Hawaiian Airlines has a strikingly better in-flight magazine than most rival airlines offer to their passengers; rather than the usual where-to-eat-dance-and-sleep tripe of so many of their competitors’ rags, Hano Hau magazine offers up in-depth, thoughtful articles on stories from environmental protectionism to pieces on obscure musicians to profiles of the work of local people. Amazingly, these profiles are sometimes even of people who live on islands that Hawaiian Airlines does not even fly to.

One of these subjects is Molokai’s own Walter Ritte, who was profiled in Hana Hou’s February/March (vol 10, no 1) edition. Presented in the article is a very even-handed, thoughtful portrait of the activist that does justice to Ritte’s desire for Molokai and to his character and personality. The piece does not shy away from mention of his arrests and time in prison, but also places great emphasis on the Hoolehua resident’s role in the genesis of the Hawaiian rights movement and his continued and unflinching capacity to stand up for what he believes in.

Cudos to Hana Hou and Hawaiian Airlines for giving their passengers such objective and intelligent food for thought, and for taking the time to listen to a man who, so often, people seem to want to muffle.

For Hana Hou's story on Ritte, visit: http://www.hanahou.com/

RESPONSE TO MOLOKAI TIMES/MOLOKAI RANCH FULL PAGE ADVERTISEMENT

Tuesday, February 13th, 2007

Dear Mr. Orodenker,

First of all, I’m overwhelmed that you would finance a whole page ad featuring me. No one has ever done that. Also, thanks for the opportunity to shed more light on this important subject. I believe the title of your recent full-page commentary, ‘Ranch is Working Together to Find Solutions’ is in error. It should read, “Ranch is Working Hard to Take Your Water.” Your company has not put an honest attempt into trying to work with the community. Instead, it has tried to shove this La’au project down their throats and hasn’t listened to what the community is saying. This is a just a last ditch attempt by a desperate developer to cash in, get out of here, and leave the community holding the bag. Your former boss, CEO #6 or #7, left and with him went all his empty promises such as, “The community will decide!” The community has decided; count the votes. What part of NO don’t you folks understand?

MPL’s vision for the future: a house on every rock, and a seal on every lawn

Tuesday, February 6th, 2007

Every now and again, one ought to just step back and marvel at the bravado with which big business presents its ideas.

Take the MPL press release following the most recent Environmental Impact Statement as a textbook example of top-notch spin-doctoring:

“It is likely that sediment discharge from runoff to the ocean will be significantly less with the Lā‘au Point project compared with existing conditions.” This conclusion is based on several measures planned for Lā‘au Point that will protect near-shore waters from increased degradation of water quality, such as drainage control systems, regulation of the use of fertilizers and pesticides, re-vegetation as a means of permanent erosion control measures throughout the developed areas, and fencing to keep deer and other animals from disturbing the soil.”

Mahalo For Asking

Tuesday, January 16th, 2007

-->

Mahalo for Asking,


Anakala Pilipo


Hawaiian Word for the Week
“AKAHAI” — “Modest, Gently, Meek”


“Pomaika’i ka po’e akahai, no ka mea, e lilo ka honua ia lakou”
“Blessed are the meek for they shall inherit the earth”

Caption: The Naupaka Kahakai. Taken by Anakala at the Kaupoa Beach Village.

Pilipo Solatario is a close friend of Anake Nona Beamer who authored this telling of Princess Naupaka. “When I can’t find something out, I look to others who know the answers. For this story, I really enjoy the way Nona’s tells it and so that’s why I chose it.

A cultural practitioner and a family historian of Halawa valley, Solatario has spent a lifetime immersed in the history of Molokai. He devotes much of his time passing stories on to both local and visitors alike. “I try to share stories that were told to me when I was young. A lot of the stories I get came directly from Molokai people.” He says many stories were passed down from his “tutu man,” a man he thought to be his grandfather but was actually his adopted mother’s first husband. Famed historian of Molokai, Aunty Harriet Nei, was also a source for many of his stories. She was also Solatario’s kumu hula.

Have Molokai questions for Anakala Pilipo? Send them to the Molokai Dispatch and we’ll make sure Anakala gets to them.

The Molokai Dispatch endorses alternatives to developing La`au Point

Sunday, October 29th, 2006

A plan, no matter how well thought out, can only benefit a community if the community supports it.

The evidence is clear that the proposed development of La`au is painfully splitting our community. The plan, which may indeed have been borne of good will, has in fact become an instrument of division, frustration and anger to this otherwise close-knit community. The tension and
polarity of this predicament can only increase if alternative actions are not taken.

“Honest dialogue between all parties should resume with more attention
devoted to alternatives to the development of La`au Point,” wrote
Elizabeth Johnson in a recent letter to the editor. I could not have suggested
it better.

There comes a time when our accumulated efforts and egos must be
temporarily put aside. There comes a time when it is necessary to forgo
our networked alliances and shed our obstinate pride. There comes a
time when we have to put away all other things so that we can see with
more clarity exactly what is happening around us.

The Molokai Dispatch supports and endorses the search for alternatives to developing La`au Point. We are committed to the vision that there
is a better way to move forward as a community.

Molokai Ranch should stop antagonizing the press

Tuesday, October 10th, 2006

By Bree Ullman

At the Office of Hawaiian Affairs (OHA) meeting two weeks ago, I noticed Molokai Ranch CEO Peter Nicholas and his wife – both wearing green “Support the Plan, Support Molokai” buttons – standing at the edge of the crowd. I snapped a quick picture or two at a comfortable distance before Nicholas stormed over and demanded that I ask permission before photographing him. “You people are very rude,” he said. I was somewhat startled – though looking back, I probably shouldn’t have been.

The Molokai Ranch pulled its last remaining advertisement from The Molokai Dispatch two weeks ago, and several sources have said that the ranch’s community affairs manager, John Sabas, has been badmouthing the newspaper at events such as meetings of the Chamber of Commerce. My last phone conversation with Nicholas went something like this.

La`au Point: Through Your Own Eyes

Saturday, September 23rd, 2006

 

For just a minute or two, take a deep breath and clear you mind of activists, developments, water rights and every other strife and struggle that has adhered itself to La`au Point. Imagine the real place that is La`au Point.

Tide pools and puka-shell-laden beaches. The soothing sound of surf rushing over golden sands. Opihi, a`ama, monk seals, eels and fish. A brilliant midday sun and the pa`akai which patiently cures in its radiance. Crisp blue night air and innumerable stars piercing the evening sky. Imagine all these things of nature. Their sum is peace itself… this is the real La`au Point.

If visions of La`au fill your heart with wonder and your head with curiosity, I suggest you make your way to there. Regardless of where you stand within the issues surrounding La`au, a visit to the place will bring you a deeper sense of clarity.

 

As citizens of Molokai, we each hold a piece of La`au’s destiny within our own actions – or inaction. Therefore we owe it to the land and to ourselves to understand as much as we can about the true nature of La`au Point. So get to the point and go see La`au for yourself.

The beach area at La`au is accessible mainly by boat or by foot. When traveling by boat, be prepared for a beach landing that will require swimming as there are no docks. Check the wind and surf forecasts for south and west facing shores before embarking. Be sure to go with a captain who has experience with the southwest shores of Molokai.

By foot, La`au Point can be reached by either of two publicly accessible areas: Hale O Lono Harbor on the south shore or Dixie Maru beach on the west. Both starting areas are several miles from the La`au Point with Dixie Maru being the shortest.

The land between both starting points is privately owned by Molokai Ranch, leaving hikers with two options. Either contact the ranch to request access (808) 660-2824, or hike along the coast. All Hawaiian shoreline, up to the high tide mark, is considered state property and is legally accessible to the public.

Hiking can take between two to four hours each way depending on the route chosen. Be sure to study a map and allow yourself ample time to complete the hike. Bring lots of water, a lunch, sunscreen and adequate footwear. It is also a good idea to bring a fully charged cell phone.

La`au is unique because it is practically untouched by man. When visiting, don’t leave anything behind but your footsteps. Don’t approach monk seals. And if fishing, fish with pride, fish responsibly.

web gallery: http:www.themolokaidispatch.com/laau/index.htm

 

GOT WATER?

Thursday, July 20th, 2006

Part 4: A serious look into current water issues finalizes the series.

Water is critical to our existence on this little island called Molokai in the middle of the Pacific Ocean, but many times it’s mired in law. Most of Hawaii’s water laws are based on English common law with a Hawaiian twist that includes native gathering rights. In the state constitution it states, “The State reaffirms and shall protect all rights, customarily and traditionally exercised for subsistence, cultural and religious purposes and possessed by ahupua`a tenants who are descendants of native Hawaiians who inhabited the Hawaiian Island prior to 1778, subject to the right of the State to regulate such rights”.

In 1990, the State Legislature enacted the State Water Code that established a priority of water rights, with Hawaiian Homesteaders and taro farmers on their ancestral lands at the top of this list. Hawaiian Homesteaders have first rights to this water and also the right to reserve water for future use of their lands. This priority is part of the state’s trust responsibility in enforcing and implementing the Hawaiian Homes Act of 1920, transferred to them by the federal government when Hawaii became a state. Yet on many occasions, the state agency responsible for enforcing the State Water Code, the Department of Land and Natural Resources Commission on Water Resource Management (CWRM), has not interpreted the law correctly.